Buffalo Beans
May 19, 2020
Jill O’Brien
Recently, a customer (thank you Suzanne) sent me a recipe for cowboy beans. It was a recipe that I was very familiar with as a kid – which we called “Hamburger Beans”. It was often dinner, or served as a side dish during outdoor cookouts.
I took her suggestions, along with notes from my mother’s recipe from years back and came up with Buffalo Beans. It’s good-ole-fashioned, stick to your ribs food. A good hunger remover after a big day. Approved by Wild Idea’s Harvest Crew!

In a heavy pot over medium high heat, heat oil and crumble in ground buffalo meat and add the onions, garlic and dry seasonings. Push the meat around in the pan breaking up the meat pieces and incorporating the spices. Cook until the meat is browned, about 10 minutes.
Add the remaining ingredients and stir to incorporate. Bring to a boil and then reduce the heat to low and simmer until desired consistency is reached.
9 comments
Thanks, Jill! I’ll probably use black & pinto beans. It sounds really yummy and a little different twist from traditional chili.
We’re doing great. Bill and I have had both of our COVID vaccines and are breathing a bit easier. Hope you and Dan are staying healthy & strong. Hoping to make a trip to the Black Hills later this year. Maybe we’ll stop in and see you again. Warm regards, Kathy
This was a big hit with my family! Subbed water for the coffee and it worked fine. Thanks, Jill!
Hi Kathy! Not OCD at all… I used black and butter beans, but any would do. Hope you are doing well! Thanks bunches. jill
I’m probably being a wee bit OCD but……what kind of beans do you use? :-)
Cindy – I would use a dark beer or water for a coffee substitute. Enjoy! jill
This looks great. Any ideas for substitutions for the coffee? Or can I just leave it out?
I fixed this dish this evening and my wife exclaimed that is this best chili dish she has ever eaten. Thank you
Holy moly buffalo lovers! If you have not tried this recipe, you are missing out. Pork and beans is big in the South, but BUFFALO BEANS takes it to a whole new level. You will never go back again. We’ve made it twice and the only changes we made are doing only one onion and putting in TWO pounds of ground WIB bison…because we are crazy about absolutely delectable WIB buffalo!