Questions? Feedback? powered by Olark live chat software
Free shipping on orders over $250
May 09, 2018


Tagged with:

Roasts ›  


Roast Buffalo Sandwiches with Chive Cream Cheese

This is a great sandwich for casual meals or picnics. Or, use the same ingredients, slicing baguettes into ovals, for open-faced cocktail sandwiches for your next party! Note: If serving a smaller group, the 1.5# English Cut Roast works nicely. Half your other ingredients and reduce the “hot” cooking time to 9 minutes. You could also make these sandwiches with grilled steak meat too!

Roast Buffalo Sandwiches 

Ingredients: Makes 9 to 12 sandwiches
1 – 3 lb. Sirloin Tip Wild Idea Buffalo Roast  (Or, 1.5# English Roast)
2 – tablespoons olive oil
2 – teaspoons sea salt, plus more for finish seasoning
1 – tablespoon black pepper
1 – teaspoon onion powder
1/2 – teaspoon garlic powder
1 - tablespoon thyme
1 – 8 oz. package cream cheese
8 – green onions, trimmed and chopped
¼ - cup caper juice
3 – baguettes


1) Rinse roast and pat dry. Rub roast with olive oil and seasonings, cover and rest at room temperature for two hours prior to cooking.

2) Pre-heat oven to 500°. Place prepped roast in a heavy pot or casserole, uncovered.

3) Place in a hot oven, closing door quickly. Reduce heat to 475°and roast for 13 minutes at 475°. Shut the oven off and leave the roast in oven for 2 hours. DO NOT OPEN OVEN DOOR.

4) Soften the cream cheese at room temperature and place in food processor with the green onions and caper juice. Pulse until incorporated.

5) Cut the baguettes into 3 or 4 sandwiches and then slice into the side leaving one side of the bread hinged. Gently remove some of the inner soft bread.

6) Spread the chive cream cheese inside of the bread.

7) Remove roast from the oven and shave roast with a slicer or slice thinly with a knife. Season sliced meat with a pinch of sea salt. *You may have pieces or ends that you don’t use that are good to nibble on or to add to a soup.

8) Pile roast buffalo into bread and sprinkle with capers.

For a charming presentation, wrap in parchment and tie with butcher string.  This helps with ease in transportation too.  The sandwiches can be made in advance and refrigerated. Remove from the refrigerator an hour before serving.



May 11, 2018

will the roast be rare, med, well done ????


January 09, 2019

What is the difference between Chuck Roast and English Roast?


January 09, 2019

Geri – Apologies for missing this questions… the roast will be medium rare.

Joni – The English Roast is from the chuck, but specifically the shoulder area.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.